Poultry Farmers File Federal Antitrust Lawsuit Against Integrators

Poultry growers recently filed a federal lawsuit against Tyson Foods, Perdue Farms, and other poultry integrators under the Sherman Antitrust Act and the Packers and Stockyards Act ("PSA"). The Growers alleged the integrators have shared data about the individual Growers without aggregating or anonymizing the information. According to the complaint, the integrators have an agreement based on this shared data not to compete for Growers' services. Todd Janzen wrote an article focusing on the ag data implications of the case. This article looks at the anti-trust aspects of the lawsuit. According to the lawsuit, the purpose and effect of the arrangement between the integrators is to fix, maintain, and/or stabilize Grower compensation below competitive levels.

Growers provide data to Agri-Stats (an ag data company based in Fort Wayne, Indiana), including compensation, breed, genetics, equipment, broiler weight, feed, medicine, transportation costs, mortality rates, average weight, monthly operating profit, and geographic location of each complex. According to the complaint, the integrators share this detailed Grower information with each other broken down by farm, flock, and plant. The result is each integrator knows the base compensation paid to each Grower by every other integrator for each specific location. The integrators therefore can monitor each other's compensation to Growers to ensure no integrator is paying more than its competitors. This information is not shared with the Growers (who are typically subject to strict confidentiality clauses). The complaint also alleges the integrators have agreed not to poach or recruit Growers from each other. 

The complaint contends there are numerous "plus factors" in the broiler industry which make it more susceptible to anti-competitive anti-trust operations. These alleged factors include:

  • high entry barriers for integrators (high costs to build processing plants and to distribute large numbers of broiler chickens); 
  • high exit barriers for Growers (substantial debt incurred to build barns and equipment to meet integrators' contractual requirements);
  • steady market supply for broilers;
  • no substitutes for broilers or the broiler system (little to no opportunity for Growers to sell broilers elsewhere);
  • industry consolidation/vertical integration; and
  • numerous opportunities for the integrators to collude (industry meetings, conferences, and visits to each other's complexes). 

Historical changes in the broiler industry are reviewed in the complaint, including the move toward vertical integration over the last 30-40 years. The complaint claims vertical integration has led to well-known competition issues in the broiler industry, as noted in several recent USDA reports. The Growers allege the integrators have monopoly power in the relevant market (the United States) and have created anticompetitive effects in the market, keeping Growers mired in debt subject to the integrators' heavy demands with no possibility of earning competitive compensation. 

The plaintiffs (the Growers) filed the lawsuit as a class action on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated who have been paid for providing broiler grow out services by the integrators since 2013. The Growers' complaint include two counts:

  1. violation of the federal Sherman Act (antitrust actions designed to suppress compensation below competitive levels); and 
  2. violation of the federal PSA (exchanging Grower data with the intent and effect of suppressing Grower compensation). 

This class action lawsuit is the first I know of to directly challenge the poultry vertical integration system to this extent. The case will test the Sherman Antitrust Act's application to the agricultural industry and relies on the PSA. As I've written before, in late 2016 the USDA promulgated new GIPSA regulations under the PSA directly applicable to competition in the poultry industry and the tournament paying system. However, the new Trump administration stayed implementation of these regulations for now. It will be interesting to watch this class action lawsuit play out in light of the GIPSA rules currently in limbo. Will other Growers join the suit? Do they have valid claims? What will the integrators' defense look like? Stay tuned...

 

 

Five Tips to Comply with the New FDA Antibiotics Rule

Five Tips to Comply with the New FDA Antibiotics Rule

As of January 1, 2017, a new FDA regulation requires a veterinarian feed directive ("VFD") from a veterinarian be in place for all antibiotics administered to livestock in feed or water. How can you stay in compliance? 

Read More
Comment

What Does the USDA's Agreement with Montana Beef Mean for You?

What Does the USDA's Agreement with Montana Beef Mean for You?

On December 22, 2016, the USDA entered into a Memorandum of Understanding ("MOU") with the Montana Beef Council ("MBC"). This MOU could affect other states' beef councils or qualified checkoff boards for other commodities. 

Read More

Where's the Beef: Are Checkoff Funds Being Used to Violate the First Amendment?

Where's the Beef: Are Checkoff Funds Being Used to Violate the First Amendment?

A lawsuit in Montana grabbed the attention of checkoff boards across the country. R-CALF sued the Montana state beef checkoff council in May, asking a federal court to prohibit the council from spending federal checkoff dollars on advertising unless the state cattle producers paying the fees have agreed to it. A federal magistrate recently issued an opinion agreeing with R-CALF.

Read More

What Do the Controversial New GIPSA Rules Really Say...and Does it Matter?

What Do the Controversial New GIPSA Rules Really Say...and Does it Matter?

New GIPSA rules were announced on Tuesday. There are plenty of opinions out there criticizing and praising the regulations, but what do the new rules really say? And, with the incoming Trump administration, does it matter?

Read More

Federal Court Says Hawaii Counties Can't Ban GMOs or Pesticides

Federal Court Says Hawaii Counties Can't Ban GMOs or Pesticides

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals struck down several Hawaii county ordinances limiting or altogether banning the use of pesticides and GMO products. The court held the local laws attempted to legislate an area already comprehensively covered by state or federal law and those local laws were preempted by state and/or federal laws.

Read More

Federal Judge Halts National Implementation of Overtime Rule

Federal Judge Halts National Implementation of Overtime Rule

A federal judge in Texas just issued an injunctive order halting the overtime rule nationwide. Judge Amos Mazzant issued a 20-page order preventing the rule from going into effect on December 1. The court wrote the injunction would preserve the status quo while the court considered the merits of the challenge to the overtime rule.

Read More

What does Trump mean for EPA's Waters of the US Rule?

What does Trump mean for EPA's Waters of the US Rule?

During the presidential campaign, Donald Trump indicated he would gut the EPA and vastly reduce the number and scope of federal regulations. Now that Trump has been elected, what can we expect from his administration on the Waters of the US (WOTUS) rule that is currently in legal limbo? 

Read More
Comment

FSMA: Preventive Controls for Human Food

FSMA: Preventive Controls for Human Food

The FSMA puts a new focus on prevention of foodborne illnesses and authorizes new Preventive Controls for facilities that process human food. 

Read More
Comment

Dozens of Groups Challenge EPA's New WOTUS Rule

Dozens of Groups Challenge EPA's New WOTUS Rule

Court of Appeals case asking the Court to overturn the EPA's new WOTUS rule. The groups argue the EPA violated the law in the way it promulgated the new WOTUS rule and ask the court to strike the rule in its entirety.

Read More
Comment

Food Safety Modernization Act: The Produce Rule

Food Safety Modernization Act: The Produce Rule

After years of legislative wrangling, rule-making, and extensive public feedback, the US Food and Drug Administration is finally implementing the Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA). The FSMA authorizes new regulations for farmers who grow certain kinds of fresh produce and for certain facilities that process food. The Standards for the Growing, Harvesting, Packing, and Holding of Produce for Human Consumption (known more commonly as the “Produce Rule”) can have an enormous effect on farmers. 

Read More

Tips for Drafting and Negotiating Livestock Production Contracts

Tips for Drafting and Negotiating Livestock Production Contracts

Today's livestock farming frequently involves negotiating production contracts between owners and growers. These agreements should include dates, prices, standards, and statutorily required language, if applicable. Owners and growers can better their negotiating position by educating themselves about the provisions typically included in such a contract. 

Read More
Comment

Drafting Crop Production Contracts

Drafting Crop Production Contracts

One of the most common agricultural agreements is the crop production contract. Each agreement will be different based on the parties, land, and risk allocation, but there are some common elements to include in any production contract. 

Read More
Comment

Swine Contracts and The Packers and Stockyards Act

Swine Contracts and The Packers and Stockyards Act

The Packers and Stockyards Act is intended to ensure fair trade practices and competitive markets for livestock, meat, and poultry. It imposes requirements on swine growers and on the contracts between integrators and growers.

Read More

Appealing Wetland Determinations: The Hawkes Decision

Appealing Wetland Determinations: The Hawkes Decision

Many farmers have been there: a state or federal governmental body says that you have protected wetlands on your property. You can't farm that land. You can't take down the tree line dividing your field. Damage or fill in that wetland and you could be subject to criminal and civil penalties. So what is a farmer to do if he thinks the government is wrong, and his land is not a wetland? The Supreme Court's recent Hawkes decision provides guidance.

Read More

Who Does Food Traceability Technology Benefit?

Who Does Food Traceability Technology Benefit?

Hundreds of established and start-up companies are working on using big data and technology to trace food from farm to table. Who benefits from this boom? The question of who benefits from food traceability is related to the question of who is responsible for food safety. Is it the farmer? The processor? The packager? The transportation company? The retailer? The consumer? All of the above?

Read More
Comment

Agriculture & Politics

Agriculture & Politics

This is NOT a blog post about what presidential candidate deserves your vote. This IS a blog post that explains where the presidential candidates stand on issues related to agriculture.

Read More

Increased Ag Technology and Sustainability

Increased Ag Technology and Sustainability

Technology is already on on the farm, but during the next decade, farmers will likely embrace ag tech like never before. Sustainability will increasingly drive technology use.

Read More

New Federal Overtime Rules in Agriculture

New Federal Overtime Rules in Agriculture

The Obama administration announced new overtime rules effective December 1, 2016. In the past, farmers generally have assumed they did not need to worry about overtime rules because of the federal agriculture exemption. This still holds true for the most part, but farms and businesses should understand how the agriculture exemption works and what the new overtime rules mean for a farm. 

Read More

Pesticide Drift Liability

Pesticide Drift Liability

Pesticide drift is the unintentional application of pesticide or herbicide. Pesticide drift can become a problem if the pesticide contacts an area or crop susceptible to the particular substance being used. There are several steps a farmer can take to prevent pesticide drift, and steps to be taken after pesticide drift allegedly already has occurred. 

Read More
Comment